I've heard both complaints and compliments about those maps.  I don't think the maps really solve anything though.  Change any map that that's been around for a year+ and people get thrown off pattern.

Like I said in my other post you can be a pussy with any weapon in the game.  Try to limit stinger usage and people will piss you off in another way.  Not really the weapon that's the problem.

I've had the maps on for less then a week so I'm not sure how many people have actually downloaded and tried these maps.

match_map - avg(match_player_count)

VCTF-Aim_ArenaOfDeath_NS - 12.9615
VCTF-ArenaOfDeath - 16.0654

VCTF-Aim_Shoebox_NS - 16.6667
VCTF-Shoebox - 17.1944