Didn't watch so I can't make an opinion but I do know some of the best UT3 DM/Dual players are on ut3pugs. Kaiser seams pretty convinced and he was in spec which gives him a better idea of what's really going on than if he was in Maximus's position.  Do the UT3Pugs servers have demos on??  Don't remember from the last time I played.  I've only played in a couple pugs but I probably should start playing more regularly :)