The three items in the pulldown menu are only effective for one match.  It's UT3's default muting capability.  Bad part about it is that UT3 had no way of doing a mute over more than one match.  Doesn't really say it's only one match in the web admin though.

That's the reason why I created the ability to permanent mute someone.  But to permanent mute someone you can't use the pulldown menu.  Go to here: http://67.202.65.160:8812/ServerAdmin/policy/permmutes (Access Policy-&gt;Muted Players) and copy and paste what you see from the Players table.