[quote=&quot;Evilone&quot;]Why would they both point to the wrong door if one of them is always right?[/quote]
k.... here we go...
Me: yo truth guy, which town will Liar guy point to as being the cool town?
Truthie: why, he'll point to My town because he's a liar.
Me: yo, liar guy, which town will Truthie point to?
Liar: why, he'll point to his town because he's the liar.

That work?