Yes, that's what people were telling me.  I had to change the gamespy ID.  I can't fix people's favorites or history though.  If you go to your master server list and you still don't see the server then there's a bigger problem than I was hoping.  I don't have this problem, so if anyone is willing to work with me then please send me a PM with how to contact you.  I may have to talk to Epic to see if they banned our server for whatever fucked up reason.